Presidential Legacy · Live

Was Bush v. Gore (2000) decided correctly?

55 votes 48 days ago Cast your vote to see the split
The facts

The U.S. Supreme Court issued its decision in Bush v. Gore on December 12, 2000, halting the Florida recount and effectively awarding the state's 25 electoral votes to George W. Bush.

Bush led Gore in Florida by 537 votes out of roughly 6 million cast after the initial machine recount.

Seven justices found equal protection problems with Florida's varying recount standards across counties, but the Court split 5-4 on the remedy of ending the recount.

The per curiam opinion stated its ruling was 'limited to the present circumstances,' a line critics and supporters have debated for two decades.

A subsequent media consortium review by the National Opinion Research Center in 2001 found Bush would have won under most, though not all, recount scenarios that had been proposed.

Cast your vote
Was Bush v. Gore (2000) decided correctly?
Live
Live results — voters
Yes — the Florida recount violated equal protection and had to be stopped0%
Yes in result, but the Court should have remanded for a uniform recount standard0%
No — the Court should have let Florida finish its recount under state law0%
No — the Court should not have taken the case at all0%
See live results from live voters
Cast your vote to unlock America’s reaction
Anonymous · one vote per person
You vs America
You matched the majority.
Your vote lines up with the current national reaction: most voters agree with you.
Your vote
VS
America
How states are voting
Not enough votes yet to show state-level results — check back as more people vote.
Compare with people like you?
Optional: pick how you describe yourself politically to unlock sharper anonymous comparisons.
Full results — votes
Your vote lines up with the current national reaction: most voters agree with you.
Yes — the Florida recount violated equal protection and had to be stopped0%
Yes in result, but the Court should have remanded for a uniform recount standard0%
No — the Court should have let Florida finish its recount under state law0%
No — the Court should not have taken the case at all0%